Back to Blog & Insights

Networking

Ask for Advice You Are Prepared to Use

Good advice seeking starts with a real decision, relevant context and the right adviser. It ends with a candid update about what changed—and what did not.

By WWA Editorial Team 3 min read
Two professionals discussing notes and service options across a conference table

A consultant is deciding whether to narrow her service offer. She asks several respected contacts, “What do you think I should focus on?” The answers are generous but scattered: specialize by industry, package one signature service, retain a broad menu, raise prices, build referrals. She thanks everyone, makes no visible change and never follows up.

Months later, those contacts cannot tell whether their time helped. The consultant may believe she was gathering perspectives. Her advisers may reasonably wonder whether she wanted insight, reassurance or simply an audience for a decision she had already made.

Advice seeking works better when it is treated as a relationship, not an information harvest. That means bringing a defined decision to a thoughtfully chosen person, sharing the context that shapes the choice and returning later to explain what changed.

Start with the decision, not the topic

“What should I focus on?” names a topic. It does not define the decision. A stronger request might be: “I am considering dropping custom workshops to concentrate on leadership-team facilitation. Over the next year, I want steadier delivery and clearer positioning, but workshops currently produce a meaningful share of my referrals. What risks would you examine before narrowing the offer?”

This version gives the adviser something usable: the proposed move, the time horizon, the desired outcome and the tension. It also makes disagreement easier. The adviser can challenge an assumption or identify missing evidence instead of guessing what kind of answer the consultant wants.

Choose the adviser with equal care. A close contact who shares your instincts may be supportive but predictable. Someone who has narrowed a professional service, bought similar services or referred clients may see a different part of the problem. If you are consulting several people, say so. That disclosure helps each person understand that you are comparing reasoning, not promising to follow one instruction.

Ask for a better next move

Future-focused questions often produce more concrete developmental input than requests for feedback. “What should I do differently in my next proposal?” directs attention toward action. “What did you think of my proposal?” can invite a general verdict, a compliment or a recap of weaknesses.

That distinction matters because useful advice must be specific enough to test. The consultant could ask, “If I present only the facilitation offer in my next three referral conversations, what confusion or resistance should I listen for?” The answer can shape an experiment. It does not require her to accept a sweeping judgment about her entire business.

A precise request can also signal competence. It shows that you have done preliminary thinking, identified the tradeoff and selected an adviser for a reason. Asking is not handing over responsibility. It is inviting another person to improve the quality of your judgment.

Close the loop, especially when you disagree

You do not owe an adviser obedience. You do owe them evidence that their effort entered a real decision. Silently discarding counsel can weaken trust, particularly when someone invested time, introduced uncomfortable considerations or believed you had asked for serious help.

After testing her options, the consultant might write: “I kept workshops, but limited them to existing clients. Your concern about losing a referral entry point changed my original plan. I did not adopt the industry specialization because my current pipeline is too mixed, but I am tracking which buyers respond to the narrower facilitation message.”

That update acknowledges both influence and disagreement. It explains the tradeoffs without pretending every suggestion was equally useful. It also gives the adviser a clearer view of the consultant’s judgment, making a future conversation more worthwhile.

Before your next request, ask yourself: What decision am I actually making? Why is this person well placed to help? What context might change their answer? And when I decide, how will I tell them what their advice changed?

Sources