Leadership
Share One Development Area Before Asking Your Team to Speak Up
When feedback requests meet polite silence, make the invitation credible: name a relevant weakness, explain the adjustment you are testing and ask colleagues to flag its effects.
Consider an illustrative studio manager whose Monday planning meetings routinely end with agreeable nods and later scheduling problems. Instead of opening the next meeting with, “Does anyone have feedback for me?”, she gets specific: “I tend to lock the production plan before checking how much revision work is still moving. This week, I am adding a midweek capacity review before confirming Friday deadlines. Please flag where that creates confusion, delays a decision or still misses hidden work.”
Her admission matters because it is tied to a recurring work problem, an observable adjustment and permission to identify consequences. The team is not being asked to judge her character or produce advice on demand. Colleagues can examine whether the new review improves planning and point to evidence when it does not.
Make the request credible
Research published in Organization Science found a meaningful distinction between seeking feedback and sharing criticism a leader had already received. In a longitudinal field experiment, leaders assigned to share prior criticism improved team psychological safety one year later, while feedback seeking alone did not. Interviews connected the durable effects to accountability and repeated practice. The practical lesson is not that one disclosure transforms a team. It is that visible ownership gives employees something more credible than an invitation.
Choose a development area that is relevant to the team’s work and within your responsibility to change. Useful topics include unclear priorities, rushed handoffs, interrupting detailed discussion, delaying decisions or arriving at reviews with conclusions already formed. Avoid sharing an intensely personal issue, an unchangeable constraint or a weakness so broad that employees must diagnose you. “I need to be a better leader” creates emotional labor. “I have been changing priorities without naming what should stop” creates a workable conversation.
Connect the gap to its operational effect. A manager might say: “When I add requests late in the week, I do not consistently remove other work. For the next month, every new priority will come with an explicit decision about what moves. If I skip that trade-off, challenge me in the project channel.” This establishes what colleagues should notice, where they should respond and what the manager will do differently.
Receive the challenge without shifting the burden
The American Psychological Association describes psychological safety as a climate where people can raise problems, seek help and take appropriate interpersonal risks. It recommends that leaders model constructive problem raising and thoughtful risk taking. Leadership analysis similarly emphasizes acknowledging gaps, accepting correction and responding without defensiveness. Those behaviors become decisive when an employee actually tests the invitation.
If someone says the new planning review still excludes freelancers’ workload, resist explaining why the omission was reasonable. Start with the substance: “You are right that their capacity is not visible here.” Ask one clarifying question, identify the next adjustment and thank the person without overpraising their bravery. A dramatic response can make ordinary challenge feel exceptional. A debate can teach everyone that correction carries a cost.
Sharing a development area is not confession. Confession centers the leader’s relief; useful disclosure centers the work. It is not theatrical vulnerability, which can feature emotion without accountability. It is also not an invitation for employees to monitor the manager’s mood, provide reassurance or design the entire solution. The leader owns the experiment and remains responsible for decisions.
Close the loop
Report back when the team has had enough time to observe the adjustment or when new information changes the plan. At a regular meeting, briefly state what colleagues flagged, what you changed and what remains unresolved. The studio manager might explain that the capacity review exposed late revision work but came too late for external collaborators, so she is moving it forward by a day.
Then keep the channel open: “Continue flagging commitments made before capacity is visible.” Repetition is the point. A manager earns more candid input by showing that challenge can alter the work, not by delivering a flawless disclosure. One relevant gap, one visible change and one calm response provide a stronger starting point than another broad request to “speak up.”
Sources
- INFORMS Organization Science (published 2021-08-17; accessed 2026-11-15)
- American Psychological Association (published 2024-03-04; accessed 2026-11-15)
- University of Virginia leadership professor Jim Detert (published 2021-07-08; accessed 2026-11-15)